top of page

Adding On Space vs. Renovating Your Current Space: A Comprehensive Comparison

Updated: Dec 7, 2023

As homeowners, the desire to enhance our living spaces is a common aspiration. When it comes to expanding or improving your home, two primary options often come to mind: adding on new space or renovating your current space. Each approach has its advantages and disadvantages, and the decision between them should be based on your specific needs, budget, and long-term goals. In this article, we'll explore the pros and cons of both options to help you make an informed choice.

Adding On Space


  • Increased Square Footage: One of the most significant advantages of adding on space is the potential for a significant increase in square footage. This is ideal if you need extra bedrooms, a larger living area, or even a new home office.

  • Customization: Adding new space allows you to design and customize it according to your preferences, making it a tailored addition to your home.

  • Potential for Higher Resale Value: Expanding your home can increase its value, especially if you add extra bedrooms, bathrooms, or other in-demand features.

  • Less Disruption: Since the construction is mostly confined to the new addition, your day-to-day life in the existing space can continue relatively undisturbed.


  • Cost: Adding on space is typically more expensive than renovating your current space. Costs can include foundation work, permits, and additional materials and labor.

  • Building Codes and Permits: Expanding your home often requires obtaining permits and adhering to local building codes, which can be time-consuming and costly.

  • Space Restrictions: Your property's size and layout may limit how much you can add on, and the design may not always align with your preferences.

Renovating Your Current Space


  • Cost-Effective: Renovating your current space is generally more budget-friendly than adding on, as it involves working with the existing structure.

  • Less Time-Consuming: Renovations typically take less time to complete than building a new addition, allowing you to enjoy your improved space sooner.

  • Greater Sustainability: Repurposing existing space is often a more environmentally friendly option, as it minimizes the need for new materials and resources.

  • Seamless Integration: Renovating your current space can allow for a seamless flow from the old to the new, creating a harmonious living environment.


  • Space Limitations: Renovations may not provide the same degree of space expansion as adding on, which can be limiting if you require a significant increase in square footage.

  • Structural Constraints: Older homes may have structural limitations that can impede renovations. Addressing these issues can be costly.

  • Disruption: Renovations can disrupt your daily life more than adding on, as they often involve work in the existing living spaces.

  • Aesthetic Incompatibility: Renovations may result in a less cohesive look if the new and old spaces do not integrate well in terms of design and materials.

Final Thoughts

The decision to add on space or renovate your current space ultimately depends on your specific needs, budget, and long-term goals. Adding on space offers the opportunity for significant expansion, customization, and potentially higher resale value but comes with a higher price tag. Renovating your current space is a more cost-effective and sustainable option, but it may have limitations in terms of space and structural constraints.

It's essential to carefully evaluate your circumstances and objectives before making a decision. Consulting with a professional architect or contractor can provide valuable insights and help you determine the best course of action. Additionally, consider your personal preferences and long-term plans for your home, as these will play a significant role in making the right choice for your living space improvement project.

If you're thinking about a renovation in Wilmington, NC, and want a team that can help you design your dreams and take the job all the way, call the team at Avocet Design Build today to turn your dreams into reality!


bottom of page